Spot ether ETF approvals remain uncertain, 'BlackRock always wins is lazy bull take', says crypto lawyer
Legal issues make the denial of spot ether ETFs by May more likely than the general sentiment, according to crypto lawyer Jake Chervinsky.Opinions on the likelihood and significance of spot ether ETF approvals this year remain varied.
“I’m not saying for certain that the spot ETH +3.94% ETF won’t be approved by May 23,” Chervinsky posted on X. “I’m just saying that the legal issues and policy environment in DC make denial (or an SEC request to withdraw) more likely than general sentiment suggests.”
With U.S. spot bitcoin ETFs launching successfully in January, attention has turned toward the prospect of spot ether ETF approvals by regulators in Washington, DC. However, SEC Chair Gary Gensler has stated that the agency’s approval of spot bitcoin ETFs was limited to the single cryptocurrency and “shouldn’t be read to be anything more than that.” Further uncertainties remain surrounding spot ether ETF approvals, given Gensler's stance that cryptocurrencies other than bitcoin are securities.
Big-name firms, including BlackRock , Fidelity and Franklin Templeton have applied for a spot ether ETF over the last few months. While many in the crypto community have cited BlackRock’s record of just one ETF denial in its history as a positive indicator of a spot ether ETF approval, Chervinsky seemingly disagrees. “‘BlackRock always wins’ is a lazy bull take,” the former Compound Labs General Counsel added.
Opinions vary on spot ether ETF approval and significance
In January, Bloomberg ETF analyst Eric Balchunas suggested there was a 70% possibility for approval by May 23 — the final deadline for the SEC to rule on a spot ether ETF application from Ark and 21Shares, the first that was filed.
In response to Chervinsky’s remarks, Balchunas said he and fellow ETF analyst James Seyffart would have new formal odds out soon. “But to be honest, and no offense to the Ethereum people but this is such small potatoes vs spot bitcoin ETFs. It's like the opening act coming on after the headliner. Using GenX bands it's like Sister Hazel trying to follow Nirvana,” he added.
The ETF Store President, Nate Geraci, disagreed with Balchunas. “Will go out on a limb early and predict spot ether ETFs will be a bigger deal than everyone thinks,” he said. “Spot bitcoin ETF demand was also severely underestimated. Whether you like it or not, ether has 1/3 market cap of bitcoin. The spot bitcoin ETF category is already approximately $50 billion. Basic math IMO.”
“Yeah I’ll stick with my Sister Hazel metaphor which is not saying ether and Hazel aren’t popular but not in Nirvana’s league. They sold 2 million albums to Nirvana's 75 million. [Bitcoin futures ETF] BITO has $2.5 billion. [Ether futures ETF] EETH has $25 million. And that’s why it’s hard to get as into it’s approval process vs bitcoin,” Balchunas replied.
Ethereum educator and angel investor Anthony Sassano also disagreed . “This comparison makes no sense at all,” he said. “BITO launched at the pico top of the last cycle and EETH launched in the middle of the bitcoin spot ETF race (meaning that people assumed a spot ETH would be coming next).”
Sassano suggested that a more appropriate comparison would be between Grayscale's products GBTC and ETHE, noting that prior to its ETF conversion on January 10, GBTC had $30 billion in assets under management, while ETHE stood at $7.3 billion.
Are spot ether ETF approvals more likely in August?
Ikigai asset management founder Travis Kling argued that expectations were more concentrated around August than May, coinciding with BlackRock’s deadline on August. 7. “Makes sense and I agree that’s the sophisticated take,” Chervinsky replied. However, “I just don’t see anything changing in law, policy, or politics to make August more likely than May,” he added.
Others suggested that, as with the conversion of its GBTC fund to a spot bitcoin ETF, Grayscale may sue the agency if it denies a similar application for a spot ether ETF. “Maybe. There’s an argument for waiting to see who wins the election instead of spending time and money on litigation right away,” Chervinsky wrote. “Regardless, this SEC hasn’t shown much fear of losing in court. Chair Gensler’s view seems to be 'if we’re not losing, we aren’t aggressive enough.'”
Disclaimer: The content of this article solely reflects the author's opinion and does not represent the platform in any capacity. This article is not intended to serve as a reference for making investment decisions.
You may also like
Wall Street sets a positive tone for the long-term prospects of AI; the Fed's interest rate path for October remains uncertain! Cooling US Treasury yields open a window for tech sector rebound?
Waller’s series of speeches at the IMF reinforced the view that cutting-edge AI technology will fundamentally reshape the economy in the long term, but he did not commit to a pause in rate hikes in October. For global semiconductor stocks, which have recently experienced heavy sell-offs and entered a correction phase, the positive aspect is that he did not further intensify short-term rate hike expectations.
Tesla's sports car can really fly!
Tesla's second-generation Roadster was unveiled at the SpaceX test site, marking a significant debut nine years after pre-orders first began in 2017. Mass production is scheduled for 2028. The new vehicle features a fan suction system and compressed air thrusters, enabling genuine "flight." Elon Musk confirmed that this will be Tesla's last model to support manual driving. Analysts predict that sales of 7,000 units in the first year could generate nearly $2 billion in revenue, with extremely high profit margins being its core commercial value.
Earnings season is here! Citadel Securities: The next few weeks will be the real stress test for U.S. stock fundamentals
The US stock market enters Q3 earnings season, with market expectations for S&P 500 earnings per share to grow 27% year-over-year, marking the third highest threshold ahead of earnings seasons since 2010. However, the growth is highly concentrated—Micron and Nvidia alone contribute 36% of expected gains. Retail investors’ weekly net buying surged to $9.1 billion, with semiconductor purchases reaching a historic peak. Citadel Securities warns that index volatility has fallen to its calmest range in nearly 30 years, while individual stock risks are quietly rising, making stock picking preferable to simply increasing index allocations.
Dangerous signal? CoreWeave founders cash out $3.3 billion after IPO
The founder's sell-off objectively avoided a 60% drop in share price, and some have already liquidated nearly 40% of their wealth. Behind this stark contrast, the company is burdened with a massive $52 billion debt, with a five-year default probability exceeding 60%. The current debt stands at $52 billion, and the cumulative negative free cash flow for 2026-2028 is projected to reach $71 billion. Its model of "borrowing at 9% interest to earn a 1% return" has been harshly criticized as the "subprime crisis" of the AI industry. The high-leverage computing power financing game is now facing the market's ultimate test.
Crypto prices
More
